You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

June 6, 2024

Potential Impact of Vietnam’s New Land Law on the Energy Sector

Subscribe to Updates

On January 18, 2024, Vietnam’s National Assembly passed a new Land Law (“Land Law 2024”) that is scheduled to take effect on January 1, 2025, replacing the current Land Law 2013. To mitigate challenges faced by the real estate market, in late May 2024, the government proposed amendments to the Land Law that would move the effective date up five months, to August 1, 2024, pending approval by the National Assembly.

One of the key sectors to be impacted by the Land Law 2024 is the energy sector, which requires large land areas for power plants and infrastructure, especially given Vietnam’s 2050 net zero emissions commitment. Below are highlights of how the new Land Law 2024 will affect Vietnam’s energy sector.

Annual payment of land rental

Under the Land Law 2013, investors implementing energy projects (e.g., solar power projects) are entitled to choose to lease land with either (i) an annual rental payment or (ii) a single upfront payment for the entire term of use. Under the Land Law 2024, these investors are only allowed to use land in the form of an annual rental payment.

As the annual land rental is calculated in five-year cycles, based on the land price table decided by the state, this new restriction means that investors in energy projects will face an additional risk of a sudden increase in land rental, disrupting their financial planning.

Investors using land sites leased with annual rental payments are also not allowed to mortgage their land-use rights, but can only mortgage assets attached to the land, at credit institutions licensed to operate in Vietnam. Accordingly, this may affect the ability of energy projects to obtain financing during the development stage, because they no longer have assets that can be mortgaged.

Obtaining land

Under the Land Law 2024, investors can obtain land through a lease without any auction or bidding process; through an auction process (for selecting the land user of a land site); or through a bidding process (for selecting the investor implementing an investment project with the need to use land).

Investors in energy projects using public investment capital and public-private partnership (PPP) projects can lease a land site from the state without an auction or bidding process. Further details on these conditions are to be provided by the government.

An auction process will apply to energy projects that intend to use land obtained from the land fund managed by the state if the following conditions are satisfied: (i) the land site is clean and does not require compensation or site-clearance work; (ii) the land site is included in the annual land-use plans approved for auction; and (iii) a 1/500 plan and auction plan are approved by the competent authorities.

A bidding process will apply to energy projects that must conduct bidding to select investors according to specialized laws, such as the laws on electricity, if the following conditions are satisfied: (i) the land is on the list of land sites subject to bidding for selection of investors for an investment project as decided by the provincial People’s Council; (ii) a detailed plan or a 1/2000 zoning plan is approved by the competent authorities; and (iii) other conditions under the laws on bidding are met.

Compared to the Land Law 2013, the Land Law 2024 supplements the bidding for projects using land as a new method for investors to gain access to land. This addition aims to increase competition and fairness for investors.

Compensation, support, and resettlement procedure

If the land for implementing an energy project is currently occupied, a compensation, support and resettlement procedure must be carried out. Under the current Land Law 2013, the decision on land recovery and the decision on the plan for compensation, support and resettlement are issued concurrently. Under the new Land Law 2024, the decision on land recovery will only be issued within 10 days after, among other conditions, the plan on compensation, support, and resettlement has been issued, if resettlement is not required; or the person whose land is recovered has had another land site allocated or handed over by a competent authority to build their own resettlement housing.

These new regulations will extend the length of the land clearance procedure considerably when the recovered land requires resettlement, as the decision on land recovery will only be issued after the resettlement is deemed completed.

Commercial arbitration as a dispute resolution mechanism

Another crucial aspect of the new law is that commercial arbitration is clearly recognized as a dispute resolution mechanism for land-related disputes. Previously, there was uncertainty surrounding whether disputes relating to land could be adjudicated by arbitration. Pursuant to the Land Law 2024, Vietnamese commercial arbitration can resolve disputes arising from commercial activities related to land in accordance with the law on commercial arbitration.

Outlook

The new Land Law aims to address overlapping and conflicting issues of related land policies and laws, while tackling practical challenges in land management and land use. It promotes the commercialization of land-use rights, fostering transparent real estate markets, modernizing land management systems, and implementing administrative and digital reforms to improve land accessibility, especially for energy projects.

Related Professionals

Industries

Energy

Practices

Real Estate

Location

RELATED INSIGHTS​ 

April 29, 2024
On November 4, 2021, Cambodia’s Ministry of Mines and Energy (MME) issued a Prakas No. 0305 on Management of the Steam Energy Subsector within the Energy Sector. The prakas aims to regulate steam energy operations, and requires companies wishing to develop, build, install, or operate steam energy to apply for a steam energy license. As this is the first prakas regulating steam energy operations in Cambodia, all relevant companies operating in steam energy must apply for a steam energy license with the MME. Prakas 0305 discusses permits for three types of activities: Development, Construction, Installation, and Operation of Steam Energy. Companies wishing to develop, build, install, and operate steam energy production facilities must first apply for a permit from the MME. Steam Energy Service Provision. Companies wishing to develop, build, install, and operate steam energy for the purpose of supplying steam energy to consumers must apply for a permit for steam energy service provider in addition to a permit for development, construction, installation, and operation of steam energy. Two-in-One Steam Energy and Electricity Production. Companies wishing to develop and operate both steam energy and electricity production activities must also apply for a permit for two-in-one steam energy and electricity production. Companies operating without the necessary permits are subject to a daily fine of KHR 400,000–4,000,000 (approx. USD 100–1,000). In addition, they may face other penalties, including: An order to halt business activities; Permit suspension; Permit revocation; Judicial action; and Other legal measures as the MME deems fit. For more information on regulations and requirements for steam energy licenses in Cambodia, please contact Tilleke & Gibbins at [email protected].
Read More
January 25, 2024
Thailand’s Department of Mineral Fuels (DMF) has developed a framework to regulate carbon capture and storage (CCS) and related activities by introducing “carbon business” to the draft amendment to the Petroleum Act B.E. 2514 (1971). CCS involves the capture, treatment, transport, and underground storage of carbon dioxide produced from industrial power generation. The captured carbon can be used to enhance oil recovery, converted into fuel such as methane or DME (dimethyl ether), or converted to higher-value products. In Thailand, various companies have carried out CCS feasibility studies. Carbon Business and Licensing Under the draft amendment to the Petroleum Act, “carbon business” is defined as exploration for purposes of carbon storage or compression of carbon into carbon storage, while “carbon” is defined as carbon dioxide in the state of gas or supercritical fluid generated as a byproduct or captured from other sources and transported for storage. Any concessionaire, product-sharing contractor, or service contract holder that has been granted permission to explore for or produce petroleum under the Petroleum Act can apply for a carbon business license from the director-general of the DMF with the approval of the Petroleum Committee. Licenses are also available to any other parties who meet the eligibility criteria to be prescribed later by a ministerial regulation. Licenses for these parties will be allocated through competitive bidding according to procedures to be announced by the minister of the Ministry of Energy (MOE). In granting a license, the minister of the MOE and the director-general of the DMF will consider the geological suitability of carbon storage, storage systems, surrounding areas of carbon storage, risk of carbon leakage and movement, environmental impacts, and the applicant’s financial potential and ability in environmental management. Responsibilities of Carbon Business Operators Carbon business operators are required to monitor and inspect their installations, structures,
Read More
January 10, 2024
On December 15, 2023, the Electricity Authority of Cambodia (EAC) issued a notification requiring all owners of solar power systems to report their systems to their local electricity supplier by January 31, 2024. Systems that have already been reported under existing regulations are exempt from this requirement. Systems that remain unreported after the deadline will be deemed illegal and subject to penalties, including possible disconnection from the national grid. The rationale for the reporting requirement is that the EAC expects to adopt a new solar power regulation soon. Electricite du Cambodge (the main state-owned utility provider in Cambodia) and EAC-licensed private electricity providers are now gathering data on the current use of solar power systems in order to prepare for, adopt, and execute the upcoming regulation. The reporting requirement is to facilitate this gathering of data. The upcoming regulation, planned for early 2024 according to the notification, follows last year’s Prakas No. 159, which contained the Ministry of Mines and Energy’s guidelines and principles for rooftop solar systems. The EAC now needs to issue implementing regulations that are in line with the ministry’s guidelines and principles. Although stand-alone solar power systems that did not have a connection to the national grid were previously not regulated and did not require any authorizations, the EAC is now stating that all types of solar power systems need to adhere to the reporting requirement under the notification. According to the EAC, the upcoming regulation will address all types of systems, and the December 15 notification clearly announces that all types of solar power systems will need to obtain EAC approval under the upcoming regulation. Solar power system operators in Cambodia should report their systems to their local electricity providers by January 31, 2024, to avoid any penalties, while remaining vigilant for the upcoming
Read More
January 3, 2024
Thailand’s Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) has issued the Notification on the Criteria for Regulating the Licensed Pool Manager B.E. 2566 (2023), which took effect on November 30, 2023. It followed an earlier notification, which took effect on October 13, 2023, that added the new license for the country’s pool gas manager. The new notification aims to regulate natural gas sale agreements and promote competition among players in the regulated natural gas market—that is, those who utilize natural gas for electricity generation under the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT) scheme, including industrial and NGV (natural gas for vehicles) consumers who rely on natural pool gas. The establishment of the pool gas scheme is aimed at encouraging new shippers to enter the market and providing new natural gas shippers with fair opportunities to compete with existing shippers, as all licensed shippers in the regulated market are subject to the same natural gas costs under this new scheme. Under this pool gas scheme, the pool manager plays a critical part in reselling natural gas in the country. Some of its responsibilities include the following: Purchasing natural gas or liquid natural gas (LNG) from licensed shippers in the regulated market at the rate at which the shippers procured the natural gas, including incidental expenses such as pipeline transportation and LNG station fees; Collecting data on the quantity and price of the gas purchased from the licensed shippers and calculating the pool gas price as specified in the ERC-approved manual, which is basically the average price of the natural gas procurement cost of all shippers in the pool; and Reselling natural gas or LNG to licensed shippers at the pool gas pricing rate in the quantity distributed to the pool by each shipper. Apart from its function in facilitating the primary procedures of
Read More