You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

February 28, 2018

Merger Control in Thailand’s Energy Sector

Informed Counsel

As policies are initiated under the Thai government’s Thailand 4.0 initiative, laying the groundwork for economic growth over the next two decades, the country’s energy demands will continue increase. The Ministry of Energy’s Thailand Power Development Plan of 2015 (PDP2015) outlines the framework for dealing with the increase in energy needs, including an expansion of installed electricity generating capacity. The PDP2015 makes it clear that the government sees private investment playing a crucial role in driving this expansion.

Thailand has added nearly 10 GW of additional capacity since 2012, increasing the country’s installed capacity from approximately 32.6 GW to 42.4 GW (as of November 2017). Much of this growth has been driven by the increase in the number of small power producers (SPPs). Installed capacity for SPPs has increased nearly threefold over the same period, from 2.6 GW in 2012 to 7.5 MW as of November 2017, now representing approximately 17.8% of the country’s total generating capacity.

As many SPP projects are reaching maturity and achieving steady, predictable returns for their investors, and as new SPP and very small power producer (VSPP) projects come online, we can expect a degree of market consolidation as producers aim to achieve economies of scale. With this in mind, it is useful to reflect on Thailand’s pre-closing approvals in the energy sector.

In most sectors of the economy, Thailand’s new Trade Competition Act B.E. 2560 (2017) provides a dual merger control system, involving premerger approvals and postmerger notifications. However, the new act is not applicable to businesses that have been governed by sector-specific antitrust and competition regulations, such as those in the energy sector.

Takeover and merger control in the energy sector is subject to a specific regime, that is, the Regulation of the Energy Regulatory Commission on the Establishment of Criteria to Prevent Mergers, Competition Lessening or Restrictions in Energy Services B.E. 2552 (2009). The regulation was promulgated by the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC), which has the authority to regulate in order to prevent the reduction of competition in the energy services sector in accordance with section 60 of the Energy Industry Act B.E. 2550 (2007).

Section 4 of the regulation stipulates that an entity which has obtained a license from the ERC is prohibited from merging with another licensee without permission from the ERC. This effectively creates a preclosing merger control regime for licensees. The definition of “merger” under section 3 of the regulation captures situations where two or more licensees amalgamate, or one licensee acquires the assets, shares, or managerial control of another licensee.

In addition to permission to merge, licensees are required to notify the ERC if any of the following events occur:

  • The licensee wishes to enter into a contract causing any person to have absolute or partial direct or indirect control over its management;
  • The licensee acts to take over, or is being taken over, pursuant to the laws relating to securities and exchange; or
  • A person who has the power to control policies, management, supervision, or administration of a licensee takes direct or indirect control of the policies, management, supervision, or administration of another licensee.

Procedurally, permission must be granted by the ERC prior to closing the proposed merger. Once the parties to the proposed merger have submitted the application, the ERC has 90 days to render its decision, which may be extended for a period of up to 15 days if the ERC deems it necessary.

Section 10 of the regulation sets out the criteria for the ERC to consider when assessing whether to grant permission for a proposed merger. That said, the criteria are fairly general in nature and leave considerable room for the ERC to exercise discretion.

In addition to the preclosing merger approval, section 5 of the regulation requires notification to the ERC in the event a licensee is acquired by a third party. Under the Regulation of the Energy Regulatory Commission on Application for License and Permission for Energy Industry Operation B.E. 2551 (2008), one of the criteria of applying for a license to operate in the energy industry is having “sufficient financial and technical potential to construct and operate in the energy industry.”

Accordingly, when a licensee is being acquired or will merge with a nonlicensee, the ERC can scrutinize the transaction to a certain degree. If the company no longer possesses the qualifications required to operate in the energy industry after closing, the ERC may revoke the company’s license.

With Thailand’s ongoing push to increase electricity generating capacity, an opportunity exists for greater participation by private investors. As more projects come online and more producers become active in the sector, we anticipate seeing greater consolidation. The ERC’s merger control regime can be expected to play an increasingly important role in future energy transactions.

RELATED INSIGHTS​ 

January 25, 2023
Thailand’s Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) has issued four new regulations under the Energy Business Act B.E. 2550 (2007) setting forth competition regimes to control both anticompetitive conduct and market structure in the energy business sector. The regulations were published in the Government Gazette on December 19, 2022, and took effect the following day. The key provisions of these ERC competition regulations largely mirror those articulated in the Trade Competition Act B.E. 2560 (2017) and its subordinate legislation. The most significant features of these competition regulations are summarized below. Market Definition Regulation The ERC’s market definition regulation (officially the ERC Regulation re: Market Definition and Relevant Market of Related Energy Services B.E. 2565) outlines the general framework for defining relevant markets in the energy sector. The factors to be taken into consideration include types of energy licenses, geographical areas, competition conditions, and interchangeability of energy services. In the annex to this regulation, the ERC has classified the relevant energy service markets as follows: Power business activities include power generation, power transmission system services, power distribution system services, power distribution services, and power system control services. Natural gas business activities include natural gas transmission through pipelines via natural gas transmission systems, natural gas procurement and wholesale via natural gas distribution systems, natural gas retail via natural gas distribution systems, and storage and regasification of liquefied natural gas. The ERC will review its market definitions and relevant energy service markets from time to time, taking into account changes in technology and competition conditions as well as feedback from public hearings. Market Dominance Regulation Under the ERC’s market dominance regulation (officially the ERC Regulation re: Criteria on Business Operator having a Market Dominance B.E. 2565), the ERC is empowered to proactively determine and declare which license-holding energy business operators have a dominant position
August 31, 2022
Thailand’s Draft Climate Change Act Countries around the world have given significant attention to climate change legislation, with many national, regional, and global attempts to slow the momentum of climate change. The most notable of these multilateral efforts is the Paris Agreement, a legally binding international treaty on climate change currently adopted by 193 parties. Its goal is to limit the global average temperature to well below 2°C (preferably below 1.5°C) above preindustrial levels, and the treaty’s coordinated efforts to combat climate change are much more ambitious than previous global agreements and discussions. Article 4 of the Paris Agreement requires countries to provide “nationally determined contributions” (NDCs), consisting of their action plans for climate action. Thailand, as a party to the Paris Agreement, has put forth an NDC that pledges to achieve an unconditional greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction target of 20% from the business-as-usual projection for 2030, with the possibility of increasing that target to 25% subject to adequate and enhanced access to technology development and transfer, financial resources, and other support. To enable the accomplishment of this pledge, Thailand is looking to enact climate change legislation that functions as a key mechanism for domestic climate action. In 2018, the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (ONEP) under the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment was assigned to prepare a draft Climate Change Act. The draft is now complete, and according to news reports it is set to be submitted to the cabinet for further consideration. The draft Climate Change Act lays out Thailand’s action plan for climate change mitigation and adaptation, including emissions reductions. Some of the key sections in the draft law involve citizen rights, the National Climate Change Policy Committee, and a national GHG database. Rights of Citizens The draft establishes the
August 26, 2022
Thailand’s Board of Investment (BOI) has extended its previously announced period for reduction of import duty on imported raw and essential materials for battery manufacturing for electric vehicles and other applications. The BOI’s announcement No. 5/2565 dated August 8, 2022, extended the reduction period to a maximum of five years. The BOI’s promoted activities list includes two battery-manufacturing business activities: Activity 4.8.3.1 – Battery manufacturing Activity 5.2.6.1 – High energy density battery manufacturing Qualifying battery manufacturers who have cell or module manufacturing processes are eligible for 90% import duty reductions on raw and essential materials that cannot be produced in Thailand. These reductions will be available on an annual basis, and are renewable for five years in total—up from the original two years. Existing projects (i.e., those which have the original two-year duration in their BOI certificate) can also benefit from the extension by preparing a project amendment form, along with a clarification letter and supporting documents, for submission to the BOI office. For more details on these customs duty reductions, or on any aspect of investment promotion in Thailand, please contact Charuwan Charoonchitsathian at [email protected] or +66 2056 5657, or Napassorn Lertussavavivat at [email protected] or +66 2056 5662.
August 16, 2022
On July 21, 2022, Vietnam’s Ministry of Industry and Trade (MOIT) submitted Report No. 126/BC-BCT to the Prime Minister regarding the mechanism for transitional wind and solar power projects. In this report, the MOIT proposed some recommendations to explicitly address difficulties for outstanding wind and solar power projects (“Transitional Projects”) which have been developed under the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 13/2020/QD-TTg dated April 6, 2020, on the development of solar power projects (Decision 13) and Decision No. 37/2011/QD-TTg dated June 29, 2011, on the development of wind power projects (Decision 37), as amended by Decision No. 39/2018/QD-TTg dated September 10, 2018 (Decision 39). The Transitional Projects primarily include those which have completed construction but have not yet been put into operation, and those which have been put into operation but for which the power price has not yet been decided, due to missing the deadline set forth under the aforementioned decisions to be eligible for the feed-in-tariff (FIT). In particular, the MOIT has proposed the following key recommendations to the Prime Minister: Mechanism for Transitional Projects The MOIT proposes two options: Option 1: Developers of the Transitional Projects negotiate and sign power purchase agreements (PPA) with Vietnam Electricity (EVN) within the price framework issued by the MOIT in accordance with the Law on Electricity, the Law on Prices, and their subordinate guiding legislation; or Option 2: The Prime Minister formulates a new decision specifying the mechanism for bidding on the purchase of power produced by the Transitional Projects, estimated to be implemented for the time limit of three years and within the price framework issued by the MOIT. Mechanism for future wind and solar power projects The MOIT proposes to apply the mechanism that developers of future wind and solar projects negotiate the power price and sign the PPA