You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

July 29, 2011

Living Wills and the Right to Refuse Life-Sustaining Medical Treatment

Subscribe to Updates
Bangkok Post, Corporate Counsellor Column

Every day, you control your health and finances. You decide whether to go to the doctor when you become ill or are injured. You also decide whether to purchase, sell, or gift your assets. In case of severe sickness or injury or death, the law must take over to best carry out your wishes.

In our July 15 column we discussed the importance of drawing up your will. Today we will discuss living wills and the right to refuse medical treatment.

For the first time in Thailand, the right to refuse medical treatment is expressly provided under Thai law. The Ministerial Regulation prescribing the rules and procedures for living wills took effect on May 20. The Ministerial Notification was issued under Section 12 of the National Health Act of 2007, which endows a person with the right to make a living will.

Before we define a living will, it is important to note certain characteristics and limitations of the instrument.

First, a living will should not be confused with a last will and testament, which provides for the distribution of an estate or assets. A living will has nothing to do with property.

Second, a living will does not allow euthanasia or mercy killing. Medical practitioners are not authorized to cause the death of their patients by performing an affirmative act, such as a lethal injection. Moreover, doctors retain the duty to relieve pain and perform other aspects of palliative care. The National Health Act of 2007 and the Ministerial Regulation relieve a healthcare provider of criminal and other liability only where the provider acts in accordance with the law, the regulation and the particular living will.

Third, a living will under Section 12 of the National Health Act does not include a medical or healthcare power of attorney, by which an individual may appoint an agent or proxy to make decisions regarding his or her health care and medical treatment in specified circumstances. Instead, the living will is a legal document through which a person may inform medical care providers, friends, and family members of his or her medical wishes, in the event that he or she is unable to communicate these wishes due to a serious illness or injury.

Meaning of a living will

A living will is also referred to as an advance directive, healthcare directive, or physician’s directive. It allows a person to make two choices in advance and in writing to (1) refuse health treatments provided merely to prolong his or her “terminal stage of life” or (2) refuse health treatments so as to cause the person to cease physical or psychological suffering caused by injury or incurable disease.

The “terminal or final stage of life” is specifically defined in the Ministerial Regulation, but can be understood by laypersons to include conditions caused by injury or incurable disease that lead to imminent death or that result in the permanent loss of brain function, which renders the person unable to communicate or comatose.

Living will requirements

A living will may be made by any person age 18 or older (referred to as a “declarant”) and should contain the following components:

  • The declarant’s full name, age, Thai identification number, and address or contact number.
  • The date the living will was made.
  • The full name and Thai identification number of the witness(es) and the relationship of such person(s) with the declarant.
  • The type of health care that the declarant does not wish to receive.
  • The full name and Thai identification number of the writer or typist (if the letter is written by another person).
  • The signature (or thumbprint, if necessary) of the declarant, witness(es), and writer or typist.

The National Health Commission Office of Thailand provides guidelines on the types of treatments that may be refused in a living will, including resuscitation, mechanical ventilation, nutritional and hydration assistance, and dialysis. If a patient is pregnant, her wishes will be followed after the birth of her child.

The intent of the declarant

Before performing under a living will, doctors must verify the patient’s intent. Per the Ministerial Regulation, such intent may be confirmed by the patient or, in the event that this is not possible, by witnesses or the patient’s relatives. As such, it is important for patients to tell their relatives and loved ones about their living will and their wishes for medical treatment.

In sum, patients are now entitled to have their living will enforced and to refuse health services that would prolong their terminal stage of life or to refuse health services in order to end their suffering. Thai law now gives patients the freedom to choose and the freedom to refuse medical treatment during the most critical time of their life.

Download Full Article
Related Professionals

Practices

Dispute Resolution and Litigation

Location

RELATED INSIGHTS​ 

May 30, 2024
A bank guarantee or bond is a powerful tool that provides contractual parties with security and assurance. Bank guarantees are commitments made by a bank (as a guarantor) on behalf of a customer (as an obligor) to a beneficiary to ensure that certain contractual obligations will be fulfilled. If the customer fails to comply with these obligations, the bank can compensate the beneficiary up to the amount specified in the bank guarantee. Bank guarantees are widely used in Thailand as a form of security and are common in construction agreements and government procurement contracts, among others. If the beneficiary (e.g., a project owner) concludes that the counterparty in the agreement (e.g., a contractor) has breached the underlying contract in some way, the beneficiary will demand payment from the bank pursuant to the guarantee. Collecting on a Guarantee and Preventing Payment In the context of construction and procurement agreements, there are two types of bank guarantees—conditional and unconditional. A conditional bank guarantee means that the project owner must satisfy certain agreed-upon conditions (e.g., provision of proof of the breach, proof of damages, or even consent from the contractor) to demand payment. An unconditional bank guarantee means that the bank must compensate the project owner for the demanded amount (up to the limit specified in the bank guarantee) without any conditions. When a project owner concludes that a contractor has breached the underlying contract (often for nonperformance or failure to comply with a representation or warranty), the project owner will demand payment from the bank holding the guarantee. Upon receiving such a demand, Thai banks will usually inform the contractor and ask if it has any objections. Even if the bank guarantee is unconditional, in practice, a bank may be reluctant to make payment if the contractor, as the bank’s customer,
Read More
May 28, 2024
Under Thai law, namely the Criminal Procedural Code, an injured person may bring a criminal case to a criminal court without having a public prosecutor file the case for him or her. After the court conducts an inquiry into the case, the court considers whether to accept the case for further trial and determine whether the defendant should be penalized accordingly. Private parties involved in certain types of cases, such as labor disputes or shareholder disputes, may find this a common channel to pursue. Criminal law in Thailand recently underwent a significant change, as new legislation changed numerous criminal offenses to become phinai-fine offenses instead. However, as this is a relatively new development, there are still instances in which plaints involving phinai fines are still being submitted to the court by these private injured persons as criminal cases. But this raises the issue of whether the court can proceed with such cases. For over a year, Thailand has enforced the Act on Phinai Fine Proceedings B.E. 2565 (2022) (ACFP) as a new legal measure to decriminalize certain types of fines for criminal penalties with less-serious offenses to phinai offenses, which results in phinai-related offenders having to pay only fines instead of facing the entire criminal procedures and penalties under the Thai Penal Code and Criminal Procedure Code, including bail submission, travel restrictions, imprisonment, and a criminal record. What happens to ongoing trials in court for phinai offenses? The ACFP automatically changed criminal offenses under 204 pieces of legislation, including certain offenses under the Bankruptcy Act B.E. 2483 (1940), the Determining Offenses Relating to Registered Partnership, Limited Partnership, Limited Company, Association, and Foundation Act B.E. 2499 (1956), the Labor Relations Act B.E. 2518 (1975), the Consumer Protection Act B.E. 2522 (1979), the Public Limited Companies Act B.E. 2535 (1992), and
Read More
May 16, 2024
On May 4, 2024, the Vietnamese government issued Decree No. 46/2024/ND-CP (“Decree 46”) amending and supplementing certain articles of Decree No. 99/2013/ND-CP dated August 29, 2013, on administrative sanctions in industrial property, as amended and supplemented in 2021 (“Decree 99”). Decree 46, which will come into force on July 1, 2024, is designed to bring Decree 99 in line with the amended IP Law of 2022. Some of the notable amendments of Decree 46 are discussed below. New Infringing Acts Decree 46 added the following new infringing acts subject to sanctions, which had not been set out in the former decree: Use of patents, utility solutions, layout designs, or industrial designs without paying compensation according to the provisions on temporary rights specified in Article 131 of the amended IP Law. Accepting a trademark license not in the form of a written contract in the case of using the licensed trademark on goods or packaging. Failure to notify clients of costs, charges, and fees related to procedures for establishing and protecting industrial property rights. Deceiving clients in the course of entering into and performing industrial property representative service contracts, but not to the extent of criminal prosecution, or forcing customers to enter into and perform industrial property representative service contracts. Although these acts are not common occurrences, it is nevertheless important to have clear regulations in order to ensure consistency with the amended IP Law and overcome difficulties and obstacles if such acts are committed in practice. Amendments and Supplements Decree 46 adopted amendments and supplements to main sanctions, additional sanctions, and remedial measures, specifically: The monetary fine imposed for violations against trade secrets is VND 50 million to VND 100 million (approx. USD 2,000 – USD 4,000), a large increase compared to the VND 5 million to VND 15
Read More
May 2, 2024
The Thai Arbitration Institute (TAI) announced on April 19, 2024, that it has jointly set up an in-court arbitration pilot project with five courts in Thailand—namely, the Civil Court, Taling Chan Civil Court, Central Intellectual Property and International Trade Court, Samut Prakan Provincial Court, and Samut Prakan Khwaeng Court. The pilot project launched on May 1, 2024. Pilot Project This project is designed to encourage the parties in cases submitted to these courts to consider having parts of the case, or even the entire case, heard and determined by arbitrators under the Civil Procedural Code (CPC). The objective of the project is to provide faster and more efficient judicial services to the public by reducing the number of cases to be fully tried in the courts through providing an option for parties to engage in in-court arbitration. Still, the court remains largely involved in the process, as the court will consider the award in detail before determining whether to render a judgment in accordance with the award without any edits. Therefore, in-court arbitration favors parties who prefer to have a court judgment instead of an out-of-court arbitral award, which could lead to enforcement challenges under the Arbitration Act. Parties who participate in this pilot project will pay the TAI a fee for its administrative assistance and related services. The TAI will assist in setting up and facilitating meetings, witness hearings, and the necessary logistics pertaining to case files involving the arbitrators, the parties, and the court. After the arbitrators hear the case, the case files, including the witness statements, exhibits, and reports during the arbitration proceedings, are collected and sent back to the respective court along with the award. Under the pilot project, the arbitrators will issue awards within 30 days of the last day of the trial or
Read More