You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

May 28, 2020

John Frangos Discusses Thai Airways Restructuring with Cirium

Subscribe to Updates

John Frangos, partner and deputy director of Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution department, and head of the firm’s aviation industry team, was recently interviewed about the Thai government’s decision to allow Thai Airways to enter restructuring proceedings for two articles by aviation industry data and analytics leader, Cirium.

The Thai government’s decision to reduce their stake in the ailing airline from 51 percent to just under 48 percent—thus relinquishing majority control—means that Thai Airways is no longer a state-owned enterprise. Instead, the company becomes privately owned for the first time in its existence.

John explains that in theory, this should allow the airline to “operate with greater flexibility and more in accordance with market demands.” He notes that political factors can have as much pull as business considerations in state-owned enterprises, and that moving out of the realm of politics will allow the airline to refocus more tightly on building the strength of the business itself.

For Thai Airways’ existing creditors and airplane lessors, this has weighty practical implications. “For lessors,” notes John, “the automatic stay means they cannot commence legal action to repossess their assets or seek a judgment for unpaid rental amounts or maintenance reserves. It also means, for practical purposes, Thai Airways may not pay rental to lessors unless the court approves.”

A crucial step for lessors at this point is to ensure that the court has a record of the outstanding debt. “Depending on the lessor’s creditor status, the lessor may have to submit a ‘debt repayment application’ and join all of Thai Airways’ other creditors to be repaid its debt,” John says in one of the Cirium articles.

Therefore, while the restructuring process is expected to be drawn out and slow-moving, lessors and creditors will need to make their voices heard in the process, and this can put them in a good position to achieve satisfactory resolution of their own matters related to Thai Airways.

Lessors will thus need to keep watch over the situation and retain the ability to act at the right moments in the process. John offers the reassurance that “Thai Airways cares deeply about its reputation and, from what I understand, has paid many of their debts up until now. These are all things which lessors have in their favour, but there is definitely going to be a period of time where lessors are not going to get paid.”

With the right strategy and timing, this period of non-payment should be kept to a minimum and can end in a beneficial outcome for the airline’s creditors.

The full articles are available to download below, or at the Cirium website (subscription required).

Download Full Article
RELATED PROFESSIONAL

Industries

Aviation

Practices

Corporate/M&A

Dispute Resolution and Litigation

Location

RELATED INSIGHTS​ 

July 16, 2021
Eric Meyer, a foreign consultant in Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution department, was profiled in the latest issue of Thai-American Business (T-AB), the quarterly magazine of the American Chamber of Commerce in Thailand (AMCHAM). As co-chair of the AMCHAM Legal Committee, Eric is extremely active in the American business community in Thailand. He applies his unique combination of legal expertise and practical awareness of business concerns in Thailand to identify topics and organize events that are interesting and relevant to a broad range of people. In the T-AB profile, Eric recounts how he came to be involved in AMCHAM after joining Tilleke & Gibbins four years ago, and notes that participation in the group has been an excellent way to stay current with the business community and build connections with professionals across various industries. In response to a question on the outlook for ease of doing business in Thailand, Eric sounded a hopeful note, explaining that the country’s strides in the areas of streamlining and digitizing various aspects of doing business should be able to continue after COVID-19, which has actually hastened digitization in several legal areas that had previously been slower to adapt to recent technological advances. Eric now looks forward to continuing to provide important leadership to the AMCHAM Legal Committee as the country and its business community seek to overcome the persistent challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic and move toward a sustainable economic recovery.
Read More
July 6, 2021
An article in Global Restructuring Review on the Thai court’s approval of Thai Airways’ business rehabilitation plan features insights from John Frangos, partner and deputy director of Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution department. The article reports that the airline’s rehabilitation plan has received court approval, over objections from two of the creditors. This step will now allow the airline—which has received over 13,000 debt repayment claims—to implement plan under the control of five administrators. John, who co-leads the firm’s regional aviation practice, explained a number of issues to the article’s author, including the Thai government’s unwillingness to bail out the financially troubled company, the challenges facing Thai Airways (and the Thai aviation industry as a whole) during the pandemic, and the historic nature of this bankruptcy case. John is representing many creditors of Thai Airways, and he shared their general reaction to the rehabilitation plan, noting that most were not necessary happy with it but did not object because they figured it was “the best deal they are going to get.” The full article is available on the Global Restructuring Review website.
Read More
June 8, 2021
The latest “Women in Law” report from Asia Business Law Journal (ABLJ) includes a profile of Tiziana Sucharitkul, co-managing partner and director of the Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution group. The special report includes profiles of 20 highly accomplished female legal professionals from the Asia-Pacific region. Tiziana is the only person from Thailand to be included in the feature. Titled “View from the Top,” the profile of Tiziana focuses on her many leadership roles—not only at the helm of Tilleke & Gibbins but also in executive and advisory positions for various global legal associations. For instance, in 2018–2019 Tiziana served as chair of the board of Lex Mundi, the world’s leading global network of independent law firms, and she currently sits on the board of the Lex Mundi Pro Bono Foundation and is an active participant in the organization’s Women’s Initiative Network to Success. Tiziana also sits on the International Bar Association’s Law Firm Management Committee, which functions as a global forum for leadership and management in the legal practice. Tiziana also spoke with ABLJ about the increasing profile of women lawyers that she has witnessed during her career, noting that she observed the concern about female representation in law firms grow throughout the 1980s and 1990s all the way until the present day, when more women can be seen in management positions, but are still somewhat underrepresented at the managing partner level overall. To read the full “Women in Law” report, please visit the ABLJ website.
Read More
April 12, 2021
Tiziana Sucharitkul, co-managing partner and director of the Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution group, has been invited to speak at a webinar on May 7, 2021, on diversity and inclusion (D&I) policies and practices at law firms. The webinar is organized by the International Bar Association (IBA) Law Firm Management Committee and will feature insights from several members of IBA leadership as well as other senior professionals from leading law firms and companies around the world. Tiziana, who sits on the committee’s advisory board, will focus especially on how Tilleke & Gibbins develops and implements D&I policies. Her presentation will also be informed by her extensive experience fostering cooperation among law firms and legal practitioners at the international level through her work with IBA, her leadership of the Lex Mundi network, and her firm-to-firm relations as a co-managing partner of Tilleke & Gibbins. The growing push for effective law firm D&I practices not only comes from internal developments but also is driven by investors who demand that companies have sound D&I policies. Law firms have been responding to these various pressures by setting D&I strategies for their own operations as well as by incorporating a D&I perspective into their client advice. This webinar will therefore delve into the practicalities of developing D&I policies for law firms and successfully carrying out those policies. For more details on the webinar, please visit the IBA website.
Read More