You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

May 28, 2020

John Frangos Discusses Thai Airways Restructuring with Cirium

Subscribe to Updates

John Frangos, partner and deputy director of Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution department, and head of the firm’s aviation industry team, was recently interviewed about the Thai government’s decision to allow Thai Airways to enter restructuring proceedings for two articles by aviation industry data and analytics leader, Cirium.

The Thai government’s decision to reduce their stake in the ailing airline from 51 percent to just under 48 percent—thus relinquishing majority control—means that Thai Airways is no longer a state-owned enterprise. Instead, the company becomes privately owned for the first time in its existence.

John explains that in theory, this should allow the airline to “operate with greater flexibility and more in accordance with market demands.” He notes that political factors can have as much pull as business considerations in state-owned enterprises, and that moving out of the realm of politics will allow the airline to refocus more tightly on building the strength of the business itself.

For Thai Airways’ existing creditors and airplane lessors, this has weighty practical implications. “For lessors,” notes John, “the automatic stay means they cannot commence legal action to repossess their assets or seek a judgment for unpaid rental amounts or maintenance reserves. It also means, for practical purposes, Thai Airways may not pay rental to lessors unless the court approves.”

A crucial step for lessors at this point is to ensure that the court has a record of the outstanding debt. “Depending on the lessor’s creditor status, the lessor may have to submit a ‘debt repayment application’ and join all of Thai Airways’ other creditors to be repaid its debt,” John says in one of the Cirium articles.

Therefore, while the restructuring process is expected to be drawn out and slow-moving, lessors and creditors will need to make their voices heard in the process, and this can put them in a good position to achieve satisfactory resolution of their own matters related to Thai Airways.

Lessors will thus need to keep watch over the situation and retain the ability to act at the right moments in the process. John offers the reassurance that “Thai Airways cares deeply about its reputation and, from what I understand, has paid many of their debts up until now. These are all things which lessors have in their favour, but there is definitely going to be a period of time where lessors are not going to get paid.”

With the right strategy and timing, this period of non-payment should be kept to a minimum and can end in a beneficial outcome for the airline’s creditors.

The full articles are available to download below, or at the Cirium website (subscription required).

Download Full Article
RELATED PROFESSIONAL

Industries

Aviation

Practices

Corporate/M&A

Dispute Resolution and Litigation

Location

RELATED INSIGHTS​ 

March 23, 2021
On March 22, John Frangos, partner and deputy director of Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution group, together with aviation lawyers and bankruptcy specialists on the American Chamber of Commerce (AMCHAM) Aerospace Council and Legal Committee, presented a webinar entitled “Bankruptcy Issues in the Aviation Industry.” In the session, John discussed airline bankruptcy, addressed debtor and creditor rights in Thai bankruptcy reorganization proceedings, explained how other aviation industry stakeholders have fared in Thai bankruptcy reorganization proceedings, and offered a comparative look at how other countries handle airline bankruptcies. As co-head of Tilleke & Gibbins’ dedicated aviation practice, John is well versed in the procedural and technical issues surrounding aviation-related disputes in Thailand, Vietnam, and elsewhere in Southeast Asia. He is frequently sought out by foreign and domestic media to comment on high-profile aviation disputes.
Read More
March 12, 2021
On February 1, 2021, the Myanmar military declared a state of emergency in the country and took control of the government, arresting State Counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi, President Win Myint, and other senior government officials from the National League for Democracy. The seizure of power, and the government’s subsequent actions to suppress public protest and dissent, have received widespread international condemnation.  The USA, Canada, and the UK have reacted by imposing economic sanctions on certain companies and individuals, and more sanctions are expected as the situation in Myanmar evolves. These sanctions pose a major concern for foreign investors with interests in Myanmar—concern which is exacerbated by the lack of clarity about the current situation on the ground. To address these issues, Lex Mundi is bringing together leading legal authorities on the topic from Myanmar, Canada, the United States, and the United Kingdom for a special webinar on March 23, 2021. The speakers, which include Tilleke & Gibbins counsel Ross Taylor, will discuss the situation on the ground in Myanmar; how the sanctions imposed this time differ from previous restrictions on Myanmar under earlier regimes; the impact of the sanctions imposed by each country; and the practical impact of sanctions on companies with operations in or relating to Myanmar. The session will be followed by a Q&A with all speakers, where attendees will be able to address any specific queries they might have. For more details and to register for this free webinar, please visit the event information page.
Read More
February 16, 2021
A recent article on the progress of the business rehabilitation of Thai Airways quotes John Frangos, partner and deputy director of Tilleke & Gibbins’ dispute resolution department, on various aspects of the developing case. The article, titled “Lessors strike deals with Thai Airways,” was written by airline industry business information provider Cirium and shared through FlightGlobal, the world’s leading publisher of news, analysis, and other content for the aviation industry. The article reports that the majority of the aircraft lessors who have exposure to Thai Airways are in the final stages of signing agreements with the beleaguered airline to govern management of their aircraft in the business restructuring process. In discussing his own experience representing various creditors in the process, John explains that the airline may be adopting a blanket policy of objecting to requests for debt repayment. “It appears to be a clear strategy of the plan preparer to object to many debt-repayment applications as a way to try to reduce the overall debt amount,” he is quoted as saying. The article also notes that there is still considerable uncertainty surrounding the ongoing business rehabilitation. Part of this is related to the future makeup of the carrier’s reduced fleet, but the most pressing issue is whether Thai Airways will submit its rehabilitation plan by the March 2, 2021, deadline. If this deadline is not met, one possibility is that the airline would have to file for dissolution. However, John considers that even if they miss the deadline, other workarounds will be explored. “If they don’t finish and they do legitimately need more time, then at least for me personally I can’t see the whole process unravelling because they can’t submit by the deadline,” he says. To read the full article, please visit the FlightGlobal website.
Read More
November 25, 2020
On November 19, 2020, Tiziana Sucharitkul, co-managing partner at Tilleke & Gibbins and director of the firm’s regional disputes resolution practice, will join a panel of managing partners from leading law firms around the world for a special roundtable seminar at the International Bar Association (IBA) Annual Conference. Originally due to be held in Miami, the 2020 conference has moved online this year under the theme “Virtually Together,” in light of the ongoing global health crisis.  
Read More