You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

August 27, 2012

Employment Subleasing: A New Form of Labor Supply in Vietnam

Subscribe to Updates
Informed Counsel

On June 18, 2012, the National Assembly of Vietnam adopted a new Labor Code which will take effect on May 1, 2013. One of the most notable issues of the new Labor Code is a provision allowing for the sublease of employees—a practice that is commonly known as labor outsourcing in other jurisdictions.

This is indeed good news for foreign investors involved in the manufacturing and construction sectors, as the nature of their business often requires seasonal workers who can provide services for a short period of time to help meet project deadlines.

Subleasing of employees has become popular in Vietnam’s industrial areas, namely, Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh City, Dong Nai, Binh Duong, and Can Tho provinces. Until recently, however, subleasing of employees has been illegal. Traditionally, the government had taken the view that this form of labor supply benefits both the employee lessor (the company providing the employees) and the employee lessee (the company receiving the employees), while the employees being outsourced are “exploited.” This is because the hiring company, typically a Vietnam-based foreign company, does not have to pay high salaries and provide correspondingly high statutory insurance schemes, which would need to be provided if they employed the workers directly. Instead, the company providing the employees, usually a local company, pays the sublet employees low salaries and provides minimal insurance schemes, while enjoying the high leasing fees themselves.

The New Subleasing Regime

In order to deal with this imbalance, while also providing companies with a commercially efficient and legally viable option, the new Labor Code stipulates that the employee lessor must pay salary to a sublet employee equal to the salary the employee lessee pays for its own employees at the same level, job, or position of equal value as the sublet employee. In addition to the salary, the employee lessor must pay statutory payment allowances and insurance for the sublet employees.

The new Labor Code legalizes the leasing of labor on the basis of the company being able to meet certain conditions as listed in the Code. Mainly, the Code necessitates a deposit from the hiring company prior to obtaining a license to lease labor. Then, it delegates the government to elaborate other conditions such as the list of the business sectors in which outsourcing is permitted.

In subleasing employees, the employee lessor and the employee lessee must enter into a written sublease agreement that contains the place of work, type of work, work and rest time, labor safety and workplace conditions, term of sublease (12 months at maximum), and the respective rights and obligations of each party toward the sublet employees, among other conditions. The sublease agreement must not contain provisions that adversely affect the rights and benefits of the sublet employees provided in their own labor contracts. In addition, the company supplying employees must notify the sublet employees of “the contents” of the sublease agreement before seconding them to the company outsourcing the employees.

At work, the sublet employee will receive instructions from the hiring company. They must follow the hiring company’s work rules and collective labor agreements provided by the employee lessee. However, in the case of a breach, the employee lessor will act as the real employer of the sublet employee, and has the power to impose disciplinary measures against the violating employee.

Unresolved Issues

In delineating the rights and duties of the related parties to the labor sublease agreement, the new Labor Code still reveals the following shortcomings that the Vietnamese government needs to address in its draft legislation guiding the Code.

First, it is hard to understand why the lawmakers impose a 12-month employment term limit in the sublease agreement, particularly since the sublet employees’ salaries cannot be lower than the salaries of the actual long-term employees of the hiring company. Also, the new Labor Code is silent on the possibility of renewal of the labor sublease agreement.

Second, there is no clear statement on how the Vietnamese labor authorities can enforce the mandatory requirement that the salaries paid to the sublet employees by the employee lessor be equal to (or more than) the employees of the employee lessee (who have the same positions or jobs). The legislation fails to outline a systematic method on how the authorities will identify which employees are at the same level. Moreover, this raises a question as to how this requirement will be applied in cases where no such employee and work position already exists in the hiring company.

Third, as mentioned above, the employee lessor must notify the sublet employees of “the contents” of the sublease agreement. This requirement seems very impractical since there is confidential information inside the sublease agreement that does not necessarily need to be disclosed to a third party, including the sublet employees. The employees’ knowledge should be limited to their rights and benefits following the sublease. They should not know any other information that might relate to trade secrets or the contract price in the sublease agreement. The Vietnamese government should therefore define the mandatory information in the sublease agreement that the employee lessor must disclose to the sublet employees.

Moving in the Right Direction

Despite these shortcomings, however, the new subleasing regime reflects the willingness of the Vietnamese legislature to provide benefits and commercial advantages to foreign investors. The new labor subleasing regime will allow investors to overcome the difficulties that lie with long-term hiring by allowing them to accommodate for seasonal demands for labor in the construction and manufacturing fields. This will not only improve operations management and encourage development initiatives for the investor, but will also enrich employment opportunities for the laborers in Vietnam without sacrificing the protections that labor gets under the Labor Code. With a few revisions, which may occur over time, the new Labor Code provisions on labor outsourcing will be a significant positive legislative development.

Download Full Article
Related Professionals

Practices

Employment

Location

RELATED INSIGHTS​ 

August 23, 2021
Since July 13, 2021, the Thai government has issued a series of resolutions offering relief measures for persons insured under sections 33 (regular employees), 39 (former employees still paying contributions to the SSO) and 40 (freelancers) of the Social Security Act B.E. 2533 (1990) (the SSA) who have been affected by the COVID-19 prevention measures under the Emergency Decree on Public Administration in Emergency Situations B.E. 2548 (2005), including the business closures required in some provinces. The latest cabinet resolution extends relief measures to SSA-insured persons in 29 provinces designated as maximum control areas (or “dark red” provinces). The provinces are grouped into three categories based on when they received that designation (which, in turn, impacts the duration of the relief which they receive): Two types of relief measures have been announced—one for parties under section 33 of the SSA, and one for parties under sections 39 and 40.   Section 33 (Regular Employees) Monetary assistance is available for Thai nationals insured under section 33 of the SSA (and their employers) engaged in the following business activities: Administrative and support activities Arts, entertainment, and recreation Automotive repair Construction Food and accommodation Information and communication activities Professional activities in science and academia Services Transportation and storage Wholesale/retail Employers must submit an application to the Social Security Office (SSO) through the online portal (www.sso.go.th/eservices) in order for them and their employees to receive the assistance payments. Each qualifying employee receives THB 2,500 per month if they are registered with the SSO within the deadline, while registered employers receive THB 3,000 per qualifying employee, up to a maximum of 200 employees (i.e., THB 600,000), as summarized in the table below.   Section 39 (Former Employees Still Paying SSO Contributions) and Section 40 (Freelancers) THB 5,000 assistance payments are available for Thai employees insured
Read More
August 23, 2021
Ho Chi Minh City has been locked down for months in an effort to fight the challenging fourth wave of the Covid-19 pandemic. We explore the various options available to employers to cut labor costs, as well as government relief measures to support both workers and employers.
Read More
August 5, 2021
With the latest wave of COVID-19 continuing to have a serious impact on Thailand, many businesses have been looking for ways to survive. Some have temporarily reduced employees’ wages, while others have resorted to a complete or partial halt to operations. In these unprecedented circumstances, it is vital that business owners understand the legal criteria and steps for implementing a temporary cessation of operations in Thailand, as outlined in this article. Any business can apply for a temporary cessation of operations under section 75 of the Labor Protection Act (LPA) if there is a necessity and a significant cause, such as the business being unable to operate as usual, and if the necessity is not considered force majeure under Thai law. (If it is deemed force majeure, an employer may be able to withhold all wages—more on this below.) If these criteria are met, the employer can choose whether to seek temporary cessation of operations on a whole or partial basis, depending on the actual situation and necessity. The employer then has to inform a labor inspection officer and the employees at least three business days in advance of the intended cessation of operations. Once this is done, operations may be halted, but the employer must pay employees at least 75 percent of their wages, calculated based on the rate on their latest working day, and these payments must continue throughout the entire cessation period. “Necessity” and force majeure Though the LPA does not indicate what qualifies as a “necessity” allowing an employer to call for a temporary cessation, past rulings from the Supreme Court provide some guidance on this issue. For instance, reduced purchase orders from customers and financial difficulties faced by the employer can amount to a situation of “necessity.” Additionally, the situation has to be significant
Read More
July 28, 2021
Lawyers from Tilleke & Gibbins’ labor and employment team including Kien Trung Trinh, Sarah Galeski, and Nam Ngoc Trinh have written the Vietnam chapter of Practical Law’s Employment and Employee Benefits Global Guide. The 2021 edition of the handbook provides a high-level comparative overview of employment laws and regulations across 32 jurisdictions around the world. Tilleke & Gibbins also contributed the Myanmar chapter of the guide. The Vietnam chapter covers a wide range of typical employment matters, such as limitations on working hours, paid leave requirements, minimum wage, and health and safety obligations. In addition, the guide provides insight on a number of topics of special interest to foreign investors doing business in Vietnam, including the following: Mandatory contents of a labor contract; Visas and permits required for expatriate employees; Employers’ obligations for protecting employees’ privacy and personal data; Procedural requirements for the dismissal of an employee; Employer and parent company liability. The 2021 edition also includes a special section on Covid-19 related provisions of labor law. To read the Vietnam chapter, click on the link below.
Read More