You are using an outdated browser and your browsing experience will not be optimal. Please update to the latest version of Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox. Install Microsoft Edge

January 24, 2019

Alan Adcock and Alec Wheatley Discuss Pharmaceutical Litigation with Asia IP

Asia IP

With a special focus on the pharmaceutical industry, the November 2018 edition of Asia IP  discusses the legal and regulatory landscape for life sciences companies across Asia. In a section of the feature focused on how best to prevent litigation, the magazine includes extensive commentary from two members of the Tilleke & Gibbins team—Alan Adcock, Partner and Deputy Director, Intellectual Property, and Alec Wheatley, Consultant.

As the starting point for protection, Alan emphasizes the importance of securing intellectual property within a company’s own walls first and foremost. “[C]ompanies operating in this space must first secure their IP in-house before seeking patent registration and moving to market,” he said. “[I]t is paramount to require all employees and contractors to sign strong employment agreements that include provisions on IP assignment, ownership, and confidentiality obligations.”

The focus of the article then turns toward the topic of generic drugs, which typically benefit from lower overall costs because they are not required to conduct full clinical trials or devote large budgets to marketing. But Alec states that this cost advantage does not necessarily place generics producers at a competitive advantage against pharmaceutical innovators: “Patented products will continue to benefit from the limited monopoly granted by patent registration for development of innovative, new drugs. This enables patent owners to build up sizable public awareness of their drugs under the brand names, which continues to inure to their benefit long past the expiration of the patent.”

To help prevent litigation between innovators and generics manufacturers, Alan proposes that regulators should require applicants of generics to disclose all related pharmaceutical patents as part of their application process with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA):  “Currently, Thailand does not have this requirement for generics—but surprisingly, it does for new drugs. This compulsory disclosure would provide greater clarity to the reviewing officer at the FDA, and could result in a reduction in the number of infringing generics granted approval in non-Bolar exemption jurisdictions,” Alan explains. “In turn, this would see a corresponding reduction in the overall potential for litigation by patent owners obliged to monitor both FDA databases for granted generic approvals and the market for infringing commercial activities.”

To read the full article, please visit the Asia IP website (subscription required).

RELATED INSIGHTS​ 

October 5, 2023
Thomas J. Treutler, partner and managing director of Tilleke & Gibbins’ Vietnam offices, was interviewed for an Asia IP article on the growing use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the realm intellectual property enforcement. The provocatively titled “Will AI bring the death of IP enforcement work?” explores the impact of AI in the IP space, and the delicate balance between helping and replacing IP professionals. In the article, Thomas is quoted as saying that “AI-powered algorithms can be trained to detect and monitor IP infringements more rapidly than a single human can, as they are able to analyze vast amounts of data on online platforms, social media and ecommerce marketplaces. This can preliminarily help rights owners and IP agents in data scraping to identify potential targets.” However, he further explained, “taking legal action requires human actions; for example, filing a complaint with the police or handling litigation proceedings in court. Therefore, it will not replace IP professionals in enforcement actions.” The full article can be read at the Asia IP website. Asia IP  is a publication of the Apex Asia Media Group, an independent publisher based in Hong Kong. The magazine aims to provide informed analysis of IP–related issues for Asian and international law firms.  
June 6, 2023
Tilleke & Gibbins is pleased to announce the addition of Nuttaphol Arammuang as a partner in the firm’s industry-leading intellectual property (IP) practice in Bangkok. In his practice, Nuttaphol focuses on providing strategic counsel and representation to corporate clients seeking to protect their IP rights. He works closely with clients to develop comprehensive strategies tailored to their specific needs, helping them to capitalize on their valuable assets and navigate the complex landscape of IP law. Drawing on his extensive experience in IP litigation, Nuttaphol will play a key role in representing clients in high-stakes disputes and advocating for their rights in the courtroom. Additionally, he will collaborate with the firm’s cross-practice, multijurisdictional teams to offer innovative solutions that address evolving challenges and opportunities in the realm of IP. “Nuttaphol’s expertise in IP litigation will further empower our clients to protect and maximize the value of their intellectual assets in today’s complex IP landscape,” said Darani Vachanavuttivong, managing partner of Tilleke & Gibbins. “We are delighted to have him join us in advocating for our clients’ rights and crafting innovative solutions in the dynamic field of IP.” Prior to joining Tilleke & Gibbins, Nuttaphol led teams of IP practitioners for several years as IP practice head and managing partner of the Thailand offices of two prominent regional law firms. Throughout his career, Nuttaphol has successfully handled a wide range of IP litigation cases, including pharmaceutical patent disputes, patent infringement, design infringement, trademark and trade dress infringement, passing off, trademark invalidation, copyright litigation in the context of new media and technology, and obtaining preliminary injunctions and Anton Piller orders. His in-depth knowledge and strategic approach have earned him a strong reputation in the legal community. As an accomplished IP practitioner, Nuttaphol Arammuang is recognized as a leading lawyer for IP in
April 19, 2023
Wiramrudee “Pink” Mokkhavesa, a partner in Tilleke & Gibbins’ intellectual property department in Bangkok, was recently interviewed about the fight against counterfeit goods on an episode of the Bangkok Podcast. Wiramrudee is highly sought after for her expertise in combating counterfeiters across the region, and is a key resource person in Thailand on anticounterfeiting measures and intellectual property enforcement. In the podcast episode, Wiramrudee spoke about Tilleke & Gibbins’ Museum of Counterfeit Goods, which is located in the firm’s Bangkok office and displays various fake products from the firm’s intellectual property enforcement work over the years. She also laid out the staggering size of the counterfeit goods market both in the region and around the word—which has been estimated to account for between 2 and 3 percent of all global trade. Together, Wiramrudee and the podcast host discussed common questions about the impact of counterfeit goods, such as whether counterfeit goods are always harmful—even when consumers are aware that the products they are buying are fake. Wiramrudee offered reasons why counterfeits are harmful, including decreased durability and the potential for harm, as well as the impact on creators and the economy as a whole. The conversation also considered the role of the Thai government in enforcing laws related to counterfeits and how Tilleke & Gibbins advises clients on protecting and capitalizing on their intellectual property as they conduct business in Thailand. To learn more about the complex issue of counterfeit goods, listen to the full podcast episode below.  
March 14, 2023
Tilleke & Gibbins is proud to be one of the founding member firms for the newly launched Sino International Professional Advisory Council (SIPAC) platform. SIPAC is a global network of law firms that offer legal services tailored to the Chinese legal market. Legal advisors partnering with SIPAC provide Chinese companies with expert advice and guidance that enable them to conduct business in key jurisdictions around the world. SIPAC aims to create a platform that connects in-house counsel at Chinese companies with a wide range of legal services, to ensure that Chinese companies can conduct business overseas with maximum efficiency. By bringing together leading firms from different countries and industries, SIPAC offers a comprehensive solution for businesses seeking expert advice on doing business in different regions of the world. As a founding member firm of SIPAC, Tilleke & Gibbins brings a wealth of expertise and experience advising clients on complex legal matters across the region. The firm has been operating in Southeast Asia for over 130 years and has a team of over 220 lawyers, making it one of the largest in the region. With the launch of SIPAC, Tilleke & Gibbins and its fellow founding member firms are well-positioned to offer customized legal and regulatory recommendations that provide Chinese businesses with increased access to overseas markets.